Do You Really Believe That For All Their Wealth, the Ampatuans Would Pay Idiots to Defend Them?
Ampatuan defense lawyer: “Is it possible that the victims died of something else before they were shot and buried?”
Prosecution witness: “It’s possible. They may have seen the checkpoint and knew they were going to die, so they decided to induce a mass fatal heart attack.”
I woke up to this dialogue being lobbed about in Facebook. Everyone found it hilarious in the same way putting chicks through paternity testing is hilarious.
Said two commenters on the PhilStar website:
“saan kaya graduate itong lawyer na ito, nakakahiya naman sa skwelahan ito or baka naman sa avenida lang nakakuha na diploma ito.”
“baka naman high lang sa shabu itong defense lawyer na ito. nag session sila ni ampatuan bago sya humarap sa press interview.
Unfortunately, I do not find this line of defense funny. I think it’s clever. Prosecution won’t take it seriously. Neither would the public. We’d all clutch at our collective sides rolling our eyes and laughing so hard we’d end up popping a collective vein or two. “That Andres Manual dude is some piece of work,” we’d hoot. “Is he dumb or just high?”
Unfortunately, he’s neither. We shouldn’t be so quick to dismiss the defense’s line of argument. They would not be taking this stance unless they’re going somewhere with it. I think I can sense what’s coming up. They’re knocking down the number of people actually killed by the suspects. Asserting that some of the victims were dead before they were shot is actually pretty clever. You cannot kill a person who’s already dead after all. So first, they will lessen the number of people actually killed then they’ll question if investigation or identification or transport of victims followed mandated processes. Little by little, they will chip away at the evidences until they establish doubt. My guess is that the Ampatuans will get off on a technicality. And no, I’m neither dumb nor high. (more…)
Hi! My name is Chin, and this is where, to quote Jane Austen, I "run mad and as often as I choose."